Orthodate

Traditions

Thanksgiving during the Nativity Fast: a practical guide for Orthodox Christians

Thanksgiving falls inside the Orthodox Nativity Fast. What the fast allows on that Thursday, how to ask your priest, and how to be a gracious guest or host.

By Orthodate Editorial15 minute read

The short answer

Can Orthodox Christians eat turkey on Thanksgiving?

It depends on your parish. On the new calendar, Thanksgiving always falls inside the Nativity Fast, which leaves out meat and dairy. Many American priests bless a relaxation for Thanksgiving Day, but this is a local custom, not a rule for the whole Church. On the old calendar, the fast usually starts after Thanksgiving. Ask your priest a week or two ahead.

Every November, Orthodox Christians in America face the same small puzzle. The country sits down to turkey and pie on a Thursday that, for most of us, falls inside a forty-day fast. There is no single answer that fits every parish, but there is a simple way to work it out. Learn what your calendar says, ask your priest early, and plan the table so that nobody, Orthodox or not, feels judged.

At a glance

Key takeaways

  • On the new calendar, Thanksgiving always falls inside the Nativity Fast. On the old calendar, the fast starts on 28 November, so Thanksgiving usually comes just before it.
  • Many American priests bless a relaxation for Thanksgiving Day. It is a widespread pastoral custom, not a churchwide rule, so ask your own priest rather than assuming.
  • The day after Thanksgiving is a Friday, which is a strict fast day. Plan the leftovers before the meal, not at the fridge on Friday morning.

1. Where Thanksgiving falls in the fast

The Nativity Fast prepares for Christmas. It lasts forty days. Churches on the new (Revised Julian) calendar keep it from 15 November to 24 December. That group includes the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese, the Antiochian Archdiocese and most parishes of the Orthodox Church in America. Churches on the old (Julian) calendar keep the same church dates, but those dates fall thirteen days later on the civil calendar. For them, the fast runs from 28 November to 6 January, and Christmas falls on 7 January. That group includes the Russian Church Outside of Russia, Serbian parishes and some parishes in other jurisdictions. Calendars have changed in some churches in recent years, so check yours.

Thanksgiving in the United States has been the fourth Thursday of November since Congress fixed the date in 1941. That means it always lands between 22 and 28 November. So for new-calendar Orthodox, Thanksgiving is always somewhere in the second week of the fast. For old-calendar Orthodox, it usually comes a few days before the fast begins. The one exception is a year when Thanksgiving falls on 28 November itself. Then it is the first day of the old-calendar fast.

The fast is sometimes called Saint Philip’s Fast, because it starts the day after the feast of the Apostle Philip. If you hear an older relative call it “Filippovka” in Russian or “Pylypivka” in Ukrainian, that is what they mean.

  • 2026: Thanksgiving is 26 November. New calendar: day 12 of the fast. Old calendar: two days before the fast starts.
  • 2027: 25 November. New calendar: inside the fast. Old calendar: before the fast.
  • 2028: 23 November. New calendar: inside the fast. Old calendar: before the fast.
  • 2029: 22 November. New calendar: inside the fast. Old calendar: before the fast.
  • 2030: 28 November. New calendar: inside the fast. Old calendar: the first day of the fast.

2. What the fast actually asks on that Thursday

The Nativity Fast is lighter than Great Lent, especially in its first weeks. The usual pattern leaves out meat, poultry, eggs and dairy for the whole forty days. Fish, wine and olive oil are allowed on many days, but not on Wednesdays and Fridays. The last stretch before Christmas becomes stricter again.

Thanksgiving is always a Thursday, and it always falls in the lighter, early part of the fast. In many American jurisdictions, that means fish, wine and oil are already allowed that day. The Antiochian Archdiocese, for example, publishes a rule that allows fish, wine and oil every day from 15 November to 11 December except Wednesdays and Fridays. Some other traditions are stricter about fish on weekdays. Your parish calendar will tell you.

So for most people, the real question is narrow. It is not “Can I eat anything at all?” It is “Can I eat the turkey, the butter in the mashed potatoes and the cream in the pie?” That narrower question is easier to bring to a priest, and easier to plan around if the answer is no.

Remember too that fasting rules are a guide for the healthy. Pregnancy, nursing, illness, some medicines, a history of eating disorders, hard physical work and old age all change what is wise. These are exactly the things to discuss with your priest, not to judge in someone else.

3. The Thanksgiving “relaxation”: what it is and what it is not

Many Orthodox priests in America bless their people to set the fast aside for Thanksgiving Day. Some announce it from the ambo or in the parish bulletin. Others simply say yes when asked. One Antiochian priest wrote on his blog that, by long American tradition, it is permissible to “let loose” on Thanksgiving and enjoy turkey with your family. That reflects a common pastoral attitude, especially in parishes with many converts and mixed families.

But it is a custom, not a canon. There is no churchwide rule that removes Thanksgiving from the fast. Some priests will bless meat for that one meal. Some will suggest you eat what is served with gratitude but skip seconds and dessert. Some will encourage you to keep the fast and bring your own dish. Each answer can be faithful. The point of asking is not to get permission to do what you already decided. It is to put the decision in the hands of someone who knows you and your parish.

A blessing to relax the fast for one day is not a blessing to drop the whole season. The fast resumes on Friday morning. Treat the day as what it is: a gift of hospitality and family peace, given for good reasons, inside a season that still matters.

  • Ask early, ideally a week or two before. Do not ask in the communion line on the Sunday before Thanksgiving.
  • Say where you will be and who will be there. “I’m going to my girlfriend’s family. They aren’t Orthodox and they’re cooking a traditional meal. What would you like me to do?” is a better question than “Is turkey okay?”
  • If your priest says to keep the fast, ask how to do it graciously as a guest. Priests have heard this question many times.
  • If you keep the old calendar and Thanksgiving falls before the fast, there is nothing to ask about meat. You may still want to talk through the Friday that follows and the Advent season ahead.

4. If you keep the fast at a full Thanksgiving table

A traditional American Thanksgiving is heavy on butter, cream and eggs, often in places you would not expect. You can still eat well, especially if you plan.

  • Usually fasting-friendly: roasted vegetables made with olive oil, cranberry sauce, plain baked or roasted potatoes, salads with oil and vinegar dressing, most fruit, nuts, olives, plain bread made without milk or eggs, and fruit sorbet.
  • Often hidden dairy or eggs: mashed potatoes, green bean casserole, stuffing (butter and stock), dinner rolls, gravy, cornbread, sweet potato casserole, pie crust and many “vegetable” sides finished with butter.
  • Fish and shellfish: if your parish rule allows fish that day, shrimp cocktail or a fish dish is an easy addition. Many parishes also treat shellfish as permitted on days when fish is not. Practice varies, so ask.
  • Bring a dish that everyone will enjoy and that you can eat freely. A large roasted vegetable tray, a bean salad or a good apple crisp made with oil instead of butter works well. Nobody needs to know it is a “fasting dish.”
  • Eat before you arrive if the menu is uncertain. Arriving hungry makes everything harder, and turning down food on an empty stomach makes you look unhappy even if you are not.
  • Watch the wine. Even on days when wine is allowed, a long afternoon of toasts adds up. Being clear-headed at a partner’s family table is wise for reasons that have nothing to do with the fast.

5. As a guest at a non-Orthodox family’s table

This is where most of the anxiety lives, especially for someone dating a person whose family is not Orthodox. You want to keep faith with the Church. You also want the cook, who may have been up since five in the morning, to feel appreciated, not inspected.

There is a long Christian thread here. When Christ sent out the seventy, He told them to “eat such things as are set before you” (Luke 10:8). The desert fathers tell many stories of monks who set aside their own fasting to receive a guest with love. Hospitality has always been allowed to bend a private discipline. That does not mean the fast is unimportant. It means love for the person in front of you is also a commandment.

In practice, most guests find a quiet middle path. Take generous helpings of the dishes you can eat. Take a small amount of something you would not normally eat if refusing would clearly hurt someone, and only if your priest is comfortable with that. Praise the food sincerely. Do not narrate your plate.

If someone asks directly, give a short, warm answer. You are not giving a lecture. You are answering a question.

  • “I’m Orthodox, and we’re in a fast before Christmas, so I’m mostly sticking to the vegetables. They’re great, by the way.”
  • “It’s a bit like Lent, but before Christmas. No meat or dairy for a few weeks. I’m not strict about making other people do it.”
  • “My priest said I could relax it today, so I’m having a little of everything. Thank you for having me.”
  • If an older relative pushes: “That’s kind of you. I’m happy with what I have.” Then change the subject to something about them.

6. If you are the one hosting

Hosting gives you more control and more responsibility. Your guests are not keeping your fast, and they should not have to. Hospitality means they leave fed, happy and feeling welcome in your home.

Many Orthodox hosts cook two tracks. They make a turkey and the classic sides for guests who want them, and a set of dishes that are fasting-friendly and good enough that everyone reaches for them. If your priest blesses a relaxation, you can simply join in. If not, nobody at the table needs to notice what you are eating.

Keep the explanation light. A short grace before the meal, said aloud, gives the day an Orthodox shape without making it a sermon. The Lord’s Prayer works for nearly every guest. So does a simple line such as “Glory to God for all things.”

If you are hosting a partner who is new to Orthodoxy, make it easy for them to ask questions without feeling tested. Do not quiz them about what they know. Show them, kindly, what the day looks like in your home.

7. Couples who keep the fast differently

Thanksgiving is often the first holiday a dating couple spends with each other’s families. It is also, for many, the first time they see how the other person keeps a fast in public. That can surface differences that were easy to ignore over coffee.

An Orthodox couple may be on different calendars, in different jurisdictions or at different stages of practice. One person may keep the fast closely. The other may barely notice it. An Orthodox person may be dating someone who is not Orthodox at all. None of this needs to become a fight at the table. It does need a short conversation beforehand.

Agree on three things before you arrive. First, what each of you plans to eat. Second, what you will say if someone asks. Third, that neither of you will comment on the other’s plate in front of family. Afterwards, talk about how it felt. Fasting habits can be a gentle window into deeper questions about how you will run a home one day.

  • Old calendar and new calendar: one of you may be fasting while the other is not. That is normal. Keep your own calendar and respect theirs.
  • Different strictness: avoid language like “real Orthodox fast.” Your partner may follow guidance from their own priest that you do not know about.
  • An Orthodox person and a non-Orthodox partner: the non-Orthodox partner does not need to fast. A small gesture, such as choosing a fasting-friendly dish alongside them, can mean a lot. It should be offered, not expected.

8. The Friday after Thanksgiving is a strict fast day

This catches people every year. Thanksgiving is a Thursday, so the next day is a Friday. In the usual rule, Fridays in the Nativity Fast are strict days: no meat or dairy, and in many traditions no fish, wine or oil either. Even if your priest blessed a relaxation for Thursday, it almost never covers Friday.

That means the classic Friday turkey sandwich is out for most Orthodox Christians on the new calendar. Plan for it. Send leftovers home with guests. Freeze some for after Christmas. Or keep a few fasting dishes back for Friday, so the fridge is not a temptation all day.

For old-calendar Orthodox, the Friday after Thanksgiving is usually still before the fast. It is still a Friday, though, and most Orthodox Christians keep Fridays all year round with no meat or dairy.

9. Making the day truly thankful

Thanksgiving fits Orthodox life better than many people realize. The central service of the Church is called the Eucharist, a Greek word for thanksgiving. Saint Paul tells Christians to “give thanks in everything” (1 Thessalonians 5:18). And one of the most loved Orthodox prayers of the last century is the Akathist of Thanksgiving, often called “Glory to God for All Things.”

That akathist was long attributed to Fr. Gregory Petrov, who died in a Soviet labor camp. Many scholars now credit it to Metropolitan Tryphon (Turkestanov), who died in 1934. Either way, it was written by someone who had every human reason to complain, and chose to give thanks instead. Many American parishes serve it, or a short thanksgiving service, on or near Thanksgiving Day. Reading it at home before the meal is a beautiful way to begin.

Gratitude also has a practical side. Some parishes host a Thanksgiving dinner for people who have nowhere to go. Others collect food for local pantries. If you are single and far from family, ask your priest whether anything like this exists. If you are hosting, think about who in your parish might be alone that day.

  • Go to a morning service if your parish has one.
  • Say grace before the meal, and include a prayer for those who are hungry or alone.
  • Ask everyone at the table to name one thing they are grateful for. It works with any guests.
  • Give something away: food to a pantry, a donation, or a seat at your own table.

10. After Thanksgiving: the rest of the season

Thanksgiving opens the American holiday season. For Orthodox Christians, it is a reminder that the fast is still running and Christmas is still a few weeks away. Office parties, holiday markets and cookie exchanges will fill December. The Church asks for a quieter December than the culture around it.

Use the weekend after Thanksgiving to plan. Decide which Christmas services you will attend. If you are dating, work out with your partner which family you will see on which date, especially if one family keeps Christmas on 25 December and the other on 7 January. Many couples find that two dates are a blessing, not a burden. Each family gets its own real celebration.

Saint Nicholas Day, on 6 December on the new calendar and 19 December on the old, is a lovely small feast in the middle of the fast. It is a good day for a small gift, a visit to someone lonely or a simple dinner together.

Plan your Thanksgiving in four steps

Do this the week before, not the morning of. It takes about twenty minutes and saves a stressful day.

  1. Step 1

    Check your calendar

    Find out whether your parish is on the new or the old calendar, and what your parish calendar says for that Thursday and Friday. If you are dating someone, check theirs too.

  2. Step 2

    Ask your priest one clear question

    Tell him where you will be, who is cooking and whether they are Orthodox. Ask what he would like you to do. Write down the answer so you are not second-guessing it at the table.

  3. Step 3

    Plan the plate and the dish you bring

    Ask the host, kindly, what is on the menu. Offer to bring one generous dish you can eat freely. Decide in advance what you will eat and what you will pass on.

  4. Step 4

    Plan Friday before Thursday ends

    Decide what happens to the leftovers. Freeze them, send them home with guests or set them aside until the fast allows them. Keep a simple fasting meal ready for Friday.

Common questions

Is Thanksgiving an Orthodox Christian holiday?

No. Thanksgiving is an American civic holiday, not a feast on the Church calendar. But gratitude is central to Orthodox life, and many American parishes serve a thanksgiving service or the Akathist “Glory to God for All Things” on or near the day.

Can Orthodox Christians eat turkey on Thanksgiving?

Only with a blessing, if your parish is on the new calendar, because the day falls in the Nativity Fast. Many American priests do bless a relaxation for Thanksgiving Day, but it is a local custom, not a churchwide rule. Ask your own priest. On the old calendar, the fast usually has not started yet.

When does the Nativity Fast start on the old calendar?

On 28 November on the civil calendar, which is 15 November on the Julian calendar. It ends with Christmas on 7 January. In most years this means Thanksgiving comes just before the old-calendar fast begins.

Is fish allowed on Thanksgiving during the Nativity Fast?

In many American jurisdictions, yes. The early weeks of the Nativity Fast usually allow fish, wine and oil on days other than Wednesday and Friday, and Thanksgiving is always a Thursday. Some traditions are stricter about fish on weekdays, so check your parish calendar.

What should I say if my partner’s family does not understand why I am fasting?

Keep it short and warm. Something like “I’m Orthodox, and we fast before Christmas, so I’m sticking mostly to the vegetables, which are great” is enough. Praise the food, thank the cook and change the subject. You are a guest, not a teacher.

Can I eat Thanksgiving leftovers on Friday?

Usually not meat or dairy leftovers if you are on the new calendar. Fridays in the Nativity Fast are strict fast days, and a relaxation for Thursday rarely covers Friday. Freeze leftovers or send them home with guests, and keep a simple fasting meal ready.

Sources and further reading